Heracleum Persicum wrote:America is 10,000 miles away from North Korea ..
No, the closest US state to North Korea is Alaska. Distance from Pyongyang to Anchorage is 6,000 km in international units, that is 3,700 miles for those who prefer
British Empire units.
NK grievances is with Japan, America has nothing to do with all this.
Those are breaking news. All their propaganda has been claiming differently for the past two generations, that's also the rationale for their nuclear deterrence as the regime presents it to the population.
Simple Minded wrote:Heracleum Persicum wrote:If Russia, South Korea and Japan solve the NK issue, it would mean US global role diminishing.
amen! The sooner the better.
Option to ignore NK nuclear armament does look attractive from a US point of view. America has nuclear deterrence aplenty, and the Pyongyang government has behaved rationally, if inhumanely, in the past.
That being said,
China may eventually find the NK joke has grown tired and not funny.
I mean, if Seoul and/or Tokyo become uneasy enough about America no longer being able to guarantee their nuclear defense against the potential or risk of Pyongyang nuclear blackmail - and decide to build national nuclear forces.
-
South Koreans favor such a force by 58% to 34%. And that was beginning 2016, when the US nuclear guarantee looked as solid as ever, since the US were out of reach for NK
- SK scientists have estimated the
time from political decision to first nuclear test to about 18 months (link in Korean, but automated translation works fine)
When Seoul and/or Tokyo have even a mere regional deterrent able to strike Pyongyang, they also will have a deterrent able to strike Beijing, because distances are not very dissimilar.
The best US policy re. this situation IMO would not be to erupt in empty threats, blusters - the
grrr-bowwow-woof version of patriotism - and demands of harsh economic sanctions that China is
not inclined to deliver - although they are ready to pretend, given that an open rebuke
à la Vladimir Putin would be humiliating for Washington, and Chinese government is not stupid enough to uselessly humiliate American one.
It would be to:
1. State publicly that when NK completes development of its Hwasong-14 missile, puting parts of US territory within the shooting zone, the US won't be able to continue guaranteeing nuclear deterrence for SK, although they will remain an ally and will continue upholding all other parts of their defense pact
2. State that consequently and in the spirit of alliance, once NK has completed Hwasong-14's development, the US will support
all adaptations of defense policy that SK may deem advisable. In particular, they will stand in the way of any attempt by the UN to sanction Seoul if it was to decide exiting the Non-Proliferation Treaty, and they will examine with a positive eye potential requests by SK for help in nuclear weapon secure handling or security of nuclear arsenals generally ("
just saying, y'know... Why, no, it's not incitement")
Then, US government could
grab the popcorn, sit down, relax and watch:
- South Koreans thinking and debating, loudly and openly
- Chinese government looking the SK debate - sweat on their front
- Japanese debating quietly, or possibly not at all. Just looking at the situation with a serene, unassuming, and mysterious
face
- Chinese government looking the Japanese busy looking mysterious -
are their hands moving? - double sweat on the front, beginning to drip
- Quite possibly, Chinese government banging Kim the Third's head against the wall
explaining that completion of Hwasong-14 development is
not called for
Anyway, it would be a good show.